After a solid year of courts beckoning to Apple’s call, it would seem that sanity is returning to European benches. Taking a queue from Germany, which is set to reject Apple’s patent case over the revised Galaxy Tab 10.1N, a Dutch court rejected Apple’s final appeal to get Samsung’s tablet banned from sale in the Netherlands. Free and Open Source Software advocate Florian Mueller reported the legal news on the FOSS Patents blog. The appeal denial is the latest in a string of many Apple defeats and few victories in the last few months.

The saga of Apple’s patent trolling in Europe is a long one, dealing almost exclusively with Samsung. the most high-profile case was the victory the scored over Samsung in Germany, where the original Galaxy Tab 10.1 was banned from import and sale after the court found it in violation of Apple’s design patents. When Samsung released the revised Galaxy Tab 10.1N, Apple once again sued for patent violation… but the German court was having none of it. Earlier this month Apple called for yet another injunction of ten of Samsung’s smartphones in Germany, though the outcome of that case is currently up in the air.

Apple is certainly wasting time on their crusade against Android, but what they’re wasting most of is money. An estimate from a Newsweek columnist put their legal expenses in a US patent case against HTC at $100 million. For their trouble, they actually won the case, barring HTC from using a phone number hyperlink feature or face a United States import ban. HTC promptly disabled the feature, giving Apple a whole lot of nothing to show for months of legal finagling and a significant chunk of stockholders’ money down the drain.

Cupertino seems to be speeding up its patently ridiculous claims in the face of failure, instead of slowing down. Expect to see more and more complaints from Apple as Android pulls further and further away from iOS in worldwide sales.

[via Cnet]


  1. I have never been a very big Apple fan.  I have all Andorid. Phones, Tablets and Google TV.  That being said.  I think Apple is really hurting themselves with all these lawsuits.  Why don’t they focus on a better product and opening things up.  A few short years ago RIM was on the top of the heap with the best products available.  Look what’s happened to them, by losing focus.

    It seems that Apple needs to regain their focus on products and customer service and people will come.  No one likes a bully!


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.