IMO, it still needs a lot of work before it can be charged for. After using it a little more, I have some cons to share: It doesn't gracefully let you out of the program to do other things. It would be nice to have a notification in the tray to let you know it's playing, what song is on, etc. like the other players do. When I try to go out to the desktop, I've had it crash on me a time or two, but otherwise, it will keep playing, just without notification.
Ricght now, the selection of the album is a one-way street, in that, you can select from the album list, and it will slide the current album out and the new one in, which is reasonably slick...but when you go past the last track in the album, or when you are in shuffle mode, when the player changes the album, it doesn't show the correct album on the right. In fact, it never seems to "lock in" on an album on the right. When you scroll, it just lands wherever, rather than "settling in" on an album. Really this app is emulating some things about Coverflow, but not quite implementing them all fully.
The share feature is sorta neat, I guess, but it seems a little gimmicky, maybe like it's just a bit of an easy feature to implement, because really, since this is a player of your own tracks, you're not really "discovering" any new music with the app. --So emailing your friends "Hey, you have to check these guys out!" seems a little unlikely. Nonetheless, it's a feature, and as long as it's not in there at the expense of leaving others out, it's nothing to complain about.
Lastly, the concerts feature is a novel idea. It appears to scan your music library for artists and give you concert dates for the artists therein corresponding to a radius you set around your location. I would assume this is why it needs course positioning (WiFi GPS) when you install it. The only problem is, it looks like it scans the entire music library. I have about 7 GB of music on my G1 right now, and after we got about halfway through the artists beginning with "B", I gave up. I imagine it would have been a neat feature, but without a way to limit the search, it's a real time-sucker. Perhaps it only needs to do the full scan once, after which it refers back to a database or something like a cache of artists to speed things up?
All in all, as I said before, it is a neat player with a lot of visual appeal and a lot of promise, but I believe it will need to be put into the market to really catch some legs. As for myself, this is something I would like to install form the market and allow the market to notify me when updates come out, to keep a close eye on it until it can replace MixZing as my default music app.



Reply With Quote
keep us up to date on it here and we'll definitely throw you some feedback (and probably some cash) I'll give it a try soon as I put music back on my sd.
Bookmarks