Stanovoy
10-30-2008, 06:44 AM
iNetwork Test
I ran the iNetwork Test app several times to generate the following results.
3G: 0.8-1.0 Mbps
WiFi: 2.8-2.9 Mbps *runs off the FiOS connection below
FiOS: 14.9-15.2 Mbps *tested off speakeasy.net via a computer
So, the 3G network is approximately 30% the speed of the WiFi connection. Keep in mind that almost no server would allow you to pull content at 2.9 Mbps. So, in reality, browsing over the 3G network is probably only a maximum of 50% slower than browsing over WiFi.
Google Maps
A more realistic test would be downloading files off the Internet. Take Google Maps for example. The large amount of image data the application requires makes it a good candidate for speed testing. The test is to load a screen full of maps, i.e. by zooming out, and is conducted multiple times.
3G: 2-4 seconds
WiFi: <1 second * only slightly under 1 second
FiOS: 0 second
Under this test, the 3G network is approximately 25-50% the speed of the WiFi connection.
Android Community
I have also conducted a real webpage load test, using AC's front page and the first article on that page. The AC pages have a lot of different content blocks, resulting in a bunch of files needing to be downloaded before the page can be fully loaded, instead of one continuous file stream.
3G: 20-22 seconds
WiFi: 17-22 second
FiOS: 4-5 second
Under this test, the 3G network is only marginally slower than the WiFi connection.
Overall, not too shabby. :D:D:D:D:D
I ran the iNetwork Test app several times to generate the following results.
3G: 0.8-1.0 Mbps
WiFi: 2.8-2.9 Mbps *runs off the FiOS connection below
FiOS: 14.9-15.2 Mbps *tested off speakeasy.net via a computer
So, the 3G network is approximately 30% the speed of the WiFi connection. Keep in mind that almost no server would allow you to pull content at 2.9 Mbps. So, in reality, browsing over the 3G network is probably only a maximum of 50% slower than browsing over WiFi.
Google Maps
A more realistic test would be downloading files off the Internet. Take Google Maps for example. The large amount of image data the application requires makes it a good candidate for speed testing. The test is to load a screen full of maps, i.e. by zooming out, and is conducted multiple times.
3G: 2-4 seconds
WiFi: <1 second * only slightly under 1 second
FiOS: 0 second
Under this test, the 3G network is approximately 25-50% the speed of the WiFi connection.
Android Community
I have also conducted a real webpage load test, using AC's front page and the first article on that page. The AC pages have a lot of different content blocks, resulting in a bunch of files needing to be downloaded before the page can be fully loaded, instead of one continuous file stream.
3G: 20-22 seconds
WiFi: 17-22 second
FiOS: 4-5 second
Under this test, the 3G network is only marginally slower than the WiFi connection.
Overall, not too shabby. :D:D:D:D:D