• Home
  • Reviews
  • Featured
  • Archives
  • Videos
  • Devices
  • Tegra
  • Send Tips
  • Contact
  • AndroidCommunity on Twitter AndroidCommunity on Facebook AndroidCommunity on Google+ AndroidCommunity RSS Feed

Android Community

    • MUST READ

      STORIES

    • Google H840 media streamer hits the FCC to replace the Nexus Q

      May 18, 2013

    • Google+ Hangouts app update adds tablet support

      May 17, 2013

    • Skobbler for Android update adds turn-by-turn navigation

      May 17, 2013

  • Trending Topics
  • Jelly Bean
  • NVIDIA
  • Galaxy S 4
  • HTC One
  • Nexus 7
  • Sell Your Used Phone

Apple shouts, ITC jumps: HTC imports banned by April 2012

7
  • By Michael Crider
  • on 19 Dec, 2011

Apple shouts, ITC jumps: HTC imports banned by April 2012

In a blow for Android, not to mention the free market, innovation and common sense, the United States International Trade commission has ruled in Apple’s favor in its case against HTC’s Android devices. Certain devices, not currently articulated, will be illegal to import into the United States as of April 19, 2012. The two companies may reach a patent settlement, or President Obama may veto the order.

Apple brought forth its case based on several patents, but the one that it won the patent case one is a system level patent, according to The Verge. The injunction will go to the desk of President Obama, who will have sixty days to veto the motion or sign it. (He’s a Blackberry guy, so we’ll call him neutral in this case.) Vetos against an ITC decision are rare, but something tells me that this case will receive particular attention.

What happens now? Normally when two large companies come to blows over patents, a licensing deal is hammered out before it actually stops sales or imports. And that may indeed happen – but if anyone is poised to buck the trend in patent litigation, it’s Apple. The company refused to settle with Samsung in their Australian patent case, forcing a long and drawn out system of appeals.

It was revealed in the recent autobiography of late apple co-founder Steve Jobs that he was furious over perceived theft of intellectual property in Android, and declared that he would “spend my last dying breath if I need to…I’m going to destroy Android because it’s a stolen product.” Apple’s non-cooperative and litigious actions in Australia and Germany seem to be in line with that imperative. Apple eventually lost the Australian case on appeal, and Samsung’s tablets are once again on sale down under.

Story Timeline

  • Samsung "can't rely on Google" for patent protection, says executive
  • ITC sides with Apple over HTC in latest patent case
  • More trouble for Android, Apple granted Slide to Unlock patent
  • Aussie judge calls Apple a monopoly in Samsung Galaxy Tab case
  • HTC may be forced to exit German market in the wake of IPCom patent case
  • Samsung Galaxy Tab ban extended in Australia
  • US judge denies Apple injunction - Samsung sales are safe for now
  • Apple loses final Australia appeal, Samsung Galaxy Tab 10.1 is ready for a retail return
  • British Telecom sues Google directly over Android patents

Apple also tried to ban Samsung from selling phones and tablets in the US based on design patents, and the injunction was denied earlier this month. Apple’s efforts to harass, stymie and generally beat Android manufacturers into economic death using the patent system have so far met with mixed results. What happens now depends upon how willing Apple is to negotiate (a factor that may have changed after Jobs’ death) and whether or not President Obama agrees with the ITC ruling.

itc_apple_order-7
itc_apple_order-6
itc_apple_order-5

itc_apple_order-4
itc_apple_order-3
itc_apple_order-2

itc_apple_order-1

Share
  • New Nexus 7 outed in Google Hangouts video
  • Verizon HTC One talk returns as the HTC PN073XX surfaces
  • Easter Eggs and Ponies found in the new Google Hangouts

Tags: AppleGooglehtclawsuitpatentsSamsung

  • http://twitter.com/Scotty_Braun Scotty Braun

    Fck Apple.. 

  • http://www.massauthentics.ecrater.com joshua hastings

    this is crazy….i can’t believe there is actually a judge that can justify taking that position while keeping a straight face. I’m guessing the new condo that he just “bought” and the boat will look nice with his new apple I-Phone he got as a parting gift!

  • Anonymous

    Truly a sad day for everything fair and open in the history of mankind. I think now is the time for every company in OHA (Open Handset Alliance) to go on complete offensive against Apple and just shut it down. Can’t anybody see that Apple is really bringing a complete Nazi era in the corporate world!

  • Doug Fiedor

    This is not a surprise because I knew Apple (Jobs) is willing to spend a lot of money to do anything they can to stop the advance of Android.   Dirty tricks like this by Apple just insures that I will NEVER buy any of their products again. 

    Y’know, after using my new ASUS Transformer tablet (with keyboard) for a couple weeks I’ve noticed a little something:  These things make a beautiful little laptop that is a real pleasure to use.  All that is missing today is a good word processor, but they are coming soon. 

    So what’s that say for Apple and Microsoft?  A tablet/laptop will be rather inexpensive and quality software will be anywhere from free to just a few bucks.  Those companies selling expensive hardware and software are going to feel that pinch within the next couple years.

    Jobs saw that coming and that is why Apple turned a room full of lawyers loose to harass any company selling Android as much as possible.  Microsoft got into that act, too.

  • TechGuy-Tech

    Maybe Apple will be the only product available in the USA and those of us elsewhere will benefit from a wider range of cheaper devices that are “dumped” on us!

    I’m all for protection of Intellectual Property if the ideas are truly novel but more often than not it just seems that patents are granted for something that is an electronic implementation of a previously existing mechanical device or action of a similar nature.

    Is an Icon that changes when you touch it really that different from an illuminated doorbell from the the 1940′s? How can “turning a page” or “locking” something be granted a patent?

    The patent system is being abused and in danger of becoming a laughing stock around the world.

  • http://www.eyes4tech.com/ Arsie

    I guess this will be a never-ending clash of the big smartphone distributors… it’s all about staying on the top and beating the competition… :(

  • http://petiksmode.com/ keeyo

    Oh come on Apple! 

  • Search

  • REVIEWS

    • AT&T LG Optimus G Pro ReviewAT&T LG Optimus G Pro Review
    • Iron Man 3 game Review: what you need to knowIron Man 3 game Review: what you need to know
    • Samsung GALAXY S 4 ReviewSamsung GALAXY S 4 Review
    • Samsung Galaxy Note 8.0 ReviewSamsung Galaxy Note 8.0 Review
    • Pebble review: Two weeks with a smartwatchPebble review: Two weeks with a smartwatch
  • HANDS-ON & QUICK LOOKS

    • Google+ Hangouts app goes live, we go hands-onGoogle+ Hangouts app goes live, we go hands-on
    • Flipboard magazines arrive with v2.0 update, we go hands-onFlipboard magazines arrive with v2.0 update, we go hands-on
    • Lenovo IdeaCentre Horizon hands-on with BlueStacks for Android gamingLenovo IdeaCentre Horizon hands-on with BlueStacks for Android gaming


  • T-Mobile G1 Accessories
  • RECENT COMMENTS

  • About
  • Contact
  • Terms of Use
  • Privacy Policy
  • Advertise

Copyright 2013 Android Community